Mrs. Boresen
Expos, 4
Contrast Essay
5/9/2010
Animal Rights vs. Animal Welfare
The question is Animal Rights or Animal Welfare? I think that everyone will agree that fair treatment of animals is important no one wants to see a creature suffer, but there is a difference between animal rights and the actual well being of the animals themselves. In this essay I will prove that what is needed in our society today is not animal rights, but instead animal welfare and education on animal welfare.
Animal Rights and animal welfare may sound like the same thing and in fact the do take the same side on some issues however there are a few key differences that set them apart. A true animal rights activist believes that Humans do not have the right to own or use an animal in any way (page 2Twelve Arguments). This means not eating meat wearing leather or using any animal products. They believe that not eating meat and not using animal products they are harming no animals, and they believe that this is the moral high ground that it is truly wrong; therefore they preach veganism. I would like for a minute to discuss veganism. This is using no animal products including eggs or other animal byproducts. This seems like it would be a great idea on the surface, however what needs to be considered is if a vegan does not use animal products what do they eat or wear? This may sound like a stupid question its plants of course, but where do these plants and vegetables come from? That may also sound like a dumb question fields of course, but now this question is not so dumb if vegetables come from fields and fields to produce have to be cleared and planted with those specific plants that we eat then what was on that land before it was cleared? The answer can vary from rabbits, birds, snakes, to any number of small life forms. Now I can speak from personal experience I have driven a tractor across a field and many small animals habitats are destroyed and they ultimately die because of it if they are not hit by the machinery its self it is a sad fact but an unavoidable one. If fields are cleared then animals die so if people eat meat or not animals are going to be sacrificed, and even if everyone in the U.S. became vegan and no large animals were killed it would mean ten times as much planting so more small animals will be killed. The simple fact is that for humans to live animals some animals must be sacrificed it’s just picking which ones is the issue (Hopkins).
Animal welfare is the most reasonable and effective cause to stand behind. Animal welfare is similar to animal rights, but with a major difference it condones the use of animals as long as it is humane (page 1 Lin). My feeling on the subject is that if animals have to be used so I can live then why fight it? Why not instead try to figure out a way to make animals lives better and cause less suffering?
Bibliography
1. Twelve Arguments against Animals." Argument One. Web. 11 May 2011.
2. Lin, Doris. "Animal Rights v. Animal Welfare." Animal Rights - Articles and Blog About Animal Rights. Web. 12 May 2011.
3. Brent Hopkins Interviewed May, 2011